AutoInvest - Feedback

Now practicing a sale. Perhaps I want to delete the ABBV stock from my pie. I have £1 ABBV but it lets me set up this. Should I be able to set £2? Shouldn’t the app only let me set as much as I have? What will happen if I confirm. Will it sell all my ABBV or tell me I do not have enough stock and then sell nothing?

It appears as an issue specific to the Android interface. The slider shouldn’t allow you to go above £1. It won’t let you sell £2 since you own less. We’ll fix the slider in the following update.

Here is the same scenario on my iOS device:
I am trying to sell Fr100 of my pie, and since I own only ~Fr60 worth of Realty income its slider is limited to that amount.

2 Likes

Just created them :muscle:t2:
Didn’t play around yet… creation was fine, the interface isn’t that comfortable on an iPhone 8, I would prefer to manage this on web later on for sure.
I got a moment of hesitation when first searched a stock and the + button was confusing at first, if it was the usual add to watch list interface or add to the pie.

So far so good :blush:

3 Likes

Been waiting ages for my screen recordings to upload to my computer to make the video on this :roll_eyes: worked flawlessly for me first time, I’ll have a closer look at how it works over time. Hope you can get STAG fractional so that I can get all my holdings into my pie!

2 Likes

It would definitely be nice if one could choose from a watchlist, rather than having to search, or indeed create a pie in one step by importing the entire contents of a watchlist.

2 Likes

I am impressed. Nice work. It is almost too much fun. Very tempting to create portfolios and add some ££s just to enjoy watching the magic happen. There is of course no fine control over the prices at which you buy, but pies are really aimed at wealth creation over the long term by regular investing, so fine tuning the buy in price is not really important.

As I have commented previously, I think people might enjoy creating their own approximations of ETFs or funds.

Vanguard FTSE High Dividend Yield ETF has yield of 4.09% and there is OCF of 0.29%. Because 15% withholding tax has been taken off that means the original yield on the holdings was (4.09+0.29)/0.85 = 5.16%. So you should be able to get better than 5% by buying stocks directly, i.e. 25% more income than you get with the Vanguard ETF. Of course you do not own as many stocks, but still, I think the performance should be good selecting a sample of 10 or so from Vanguard’s high dividend paying holdings.

Another thing one can do is pick the top 10 holdings of a successful fund like Fundsmith and own it without the 0.9% management fee, and with better dividend yield.

10 Likes

3 posts were merged into an existing topic: AutoInvest - Join the BETA

Is it posible to increase the max cap of 50 stocks i wuold like to add all my 55 dividend stocks to the same pie

1 Like

We’re starting with a limit of 50 but will increase it gradually.

2 Likes

Hey,
So few questions.
I understand we will not be able to see our current holdings in pies for the moment, any idea when this will be supported?
As I am not planning to get into new companies and only plan to grow my current holdings, If i’ll duplicate my portfolio into a pie and use auto invest and DRIP, will I be able to merge my holdings in one pie at some point?
Thank you

I got so happy when I received the notification for AutoInvest and immediately started to “cook” my testing pie. Everything went smoothly and, as I saw from the teasing period before launch, very intuitive and easy to follow steps. Half of the pie is already done (waiting for the European markets to open for the rest to get filled). I will see how it goes from now on.

Congrats for all the work of the team (especially in this period) and for being opened and responsive to your client base. This one is a big one and it’s something I dreamt since I joined the platform (it’s even more than I was wishing for). I hope soon I can try the AutoInvest at full capacity with my targeted pie.

6 Likes

I can see my pies on desktop :slight_smile:

5 Likes

If tomorrow we allow the migration of existing holdings into pies, very soon there might be hundreds of millions managed by AutoInvest. It’s better to wait until all the bugs are cleared and people get gradually familiar with AutoInvest and pies.

17 Likes

Great, I fully agree. thank you.
And what about my second question?
As I am not planning to get into new companies and only plan to grow my current holdings, If i’ll duplicate my portfolio into a pie and use auto invest and DRIP, will I be able to merge my holdings in one pie at some point?
Thank you

2 Likes

It’s revolutionary. Period.

6 Likes

This is brilliant! Expect to hear it in our next YouTube advert.

8 Likes

I have found that the secret to becoming rich is just to invest in AMD :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

9 Likes

It really is. To visualise your future gains and plan your savings with multiple stocks in pies, well, you guys should be proud.

3 Likes

With a 87% avg. annual return what can you expect :woman_shrugging: :slight_smile:

4 Likes

I only had a brief test with the new features today but what I have seen looks to be very good.

I was surprised how clear, concise and easy to use all the new features are while providing a lot of customisability. I liked how when set up my pie and some of the investment was for a closed market those funds were reserved and clearly marked.

My feedback would be able to manually set the goal on pie creation and to be able to tweak the annual return % to be able to make your own value projection.

3 Likes