I think this cash pot split absolutely terrible, with no reasonable use case.
I have gone back and forth a bit with support, and they are under the impression that forcing this on us is for our benefit, as opposed to just making our lives harder.
I would understand if they said something about regulation and separation of investments vs spending, or if they said that this makes Trading212’s life simpler in some way.
Or even if this were a trick to reduce how much interest they would pay out on cash. Like how banks make you split your balance into your current account and your savings account, where every drop you keep in the current account is money that earns much less interest (or none at all). Basically regular banks add this two-pot complexity, but at least they do it in order to trick their customers out of money.
But no. Trading212 mentions no regulatory requirements, and both pots would continue to earn the same interest.
So it’s just an extra hurdle, for no reason.
I’m trying to rack my brain about why anybody would want this. The only thing I can come up with is that maybe this is for people who cannot help but every month immediately spend any and all money they have, until all their cards are declined. And they could potentially be helped by some cash being “locked away” unattached to any card. If that’s a typical person, then that makes me sad. Even then, shouldn’t these people move their savings not to the “Main pot”, but to a Cash ISA? It’s a flexible ISA, right? So it’d be no more locked up than the “Main Pot”.
If this is why you want to add complexity and hurdles by splitting the cash pot, then I feel like I’m being punished and needing to suffer just because other people are failing to plan. And really, is it Trading212’s responsibility to force these people to behave better?
One way to fix this feature is to:
- Allow investing directly from the Spending Pot; and
- Allow me to choose to get all interest deposited into the Spending Pot.
(both are needed)
Alternatively:
- Allow me to tie my card (physical and virtual) to the Main Pot.
That way I can keep a zero balance on my “Other Pot”, and pretend that T212 doesn’t even have this complication.