Baillie Gifford [discussion] šŸ“ƒ

Thanks for sharing. It’s not just SMT, but the broad market and its cycles that’s negatively impacted, so I don’t understand what could the fund have done differently … well, it’s easy to have the answers directed to the past, but still.

His concerns about the private equity exposure seem reasonable and I think it can be helpful to have dissenting voices around the table.

The FT story – by Dan McCrum, of Wirecard fame – makes the point that the chair should have retired by now in line with the corporate governance code.

Bhide adds: ā€œMy concern is that no one on the board has any professional investment experience. This board desperately needed people who knew what they are doing.ā€

While it’s important to remember he has an axe to grind, it is concerning to hear him question the chair’s independence: "Her role so far as I can see is to protect managers from criticism.ā€

Scottish Mortgage Investor Webinar
https://www.scottishmortgage.com/en/uk/individual-investors/insights/ic-video/2023-q1-scottish-mortgage-your-questions-answered-10019535

This is good news for investors. MNTN shares up 6-7% today. Hopefully, this provides confidence in the valuations of private equities held by Baillie Gifford.

An infographic about Cloud computing by SMT.

MNTN is tempting with a 57% discount and the share price down more than 50% this year. It’s a shame the trust’s relatively illiquid and the spread’s so wide.

image

Sorry to go out of topic…is todays BATS reporting impairment charge 25 or 31 Billion. Am getting confused?

T212 says 31 Billion
HL says 25 Billion

Hey, @Zrtz :wave:

It seems like the information provided by HL presents the impairment charge in GBP, while our notification presents it in USD.

As you know, BATS announced a £25 billion impairment charge earlier today. Using the current exchange rates, £25 billion equals $31.5 billion. Apologies if we have caused any confusion :pray:

This was an interesting read. It’s worth noting that the 32% is in the riskier end of private equity.

For those interested in SMT, it’s Monthly LinkedIn Newsletter (with subscription option):

It’s interesting that the managers have lost faith in Illumina, though I can hardly blame them after the whole Grail debacle.

Northvolt might be the one that leads an IPO revival. That could really sure up SMT.

It’s all gone very quiet around here :laughing:

I no longer own any BG funds though I do use SMT’s holdings as a bit of a screener for individual investments and I hold some of the same companies.

The managers have been doing some spring cleaning which is no bad thing because, for me, the portfolio needed thinning out.

Carvana, Beam, Chargepoint, Lilium, Nio, Illumina, Hellofresh, Zoom, Tencent and more have all been shown the door.

I’m glad to see Slater and Burns starting to put more of their own stamp on SMT.

Interesting. SpaceX became the biggest holding!

This was part of the reason I sold SMT, I was getting uncomfortable with the 30%ish private holdings, and I wanted to bank a bounce.

I know the managers have since slashed the Tesla holding but it’s still 9%ish combined with SpaceX.

I balked at the concentration in Musk as he was beginning to dabble more in politics.

I’m considering building up a position in MNTN, to give me some exposure that I have more control over, when a good entry point arises.

It’s planning to move to the main market from the specialist fund segment which I’m hoping will bring better execution.

I’m doing some research to try to understand what this actually means but you’d imagine it would include higher standards of governance etc.

This article suggests the fund would be more liquid and denominated in sterling rather than USD.

Interesting, thanks for the feedback.
The ongoing charges are high, though. :thinking:

Ongoing charges 0,92 %

Yes, execution’s pretty horrendous too.

SMT remains a cheaper, more liquid way of getting exposure to many of the same private firms.

I hold many of the same public companies individually, so SMT doesn’t make as much sense to me any more.

But I won’t be rushing into buying MNTN. I’ve lots more research to do on this one.

Any SMT maximalists left?

I’m a holder for over 5 years, but …

Yeah same. They’ve never fully recovered from 2021 and their subsequent rebalancing hasn’t really worked. But I’ve made a decent amount in the SIPP and now keen to sell if there’s a better option out there but I haven’t done any research in a year or so as letting things grow and breathe.

Feels like we might be nearing the end of another tech cycle.