not unless you choose to rebalanceā¦
Will the import/export be in the first release or a subsequent release?
Are the received dividends calculated in the total return of a pie?
And in the return of a stock within a pie?
I miss the possibility to sell a spezific count of a stock from pie.
I canāt sell / remove a slice from a Pieā¦ I tried so far:
1 - remove the stock/slice, tried to withdraw and it fails multiple times.
2 - added it back to Pie, set it to 0.5%, tried to withdraw multiple times, fails.
Hey @laguiar ,
Can you check your messages? Iāll send you a DM 
Hello,
Some feedback on general usage.
Buying mostly is fluid, there have been times where specific stock was in investing mode for 30+ min, for example yesterday 20.07.2020, 21:04 GMT+2 āTā was just waiting to be purchased. However when I did manual purchase of same value in fractional outside of Pie it bought in 20seconds.
What is most problematic is āpocket change investingā, anything with XXX.10 or similar never or rarely gets invested.
So for instance I get some dividend 4.42$, I was rarely able to invest .42 without adding my own .58$.
Probably due to fractional not being āfractional enoughā?
Selling however is very clunky, I know it is long term investing, buy n hold etc.
But I never had fully successful sell if I was removing 2 or more positions from Pie. Always some stock failed with 0.12 or similar left or just failed altogether.
Also I think there should be much simpler solution to sell position then have to check current value and then hope you get the ~xxx.xx because otherwise it doesnāt sell the position at all just states failed.
I would think if I remove position I would be prompted after confirming pie weightings to sell the position automatically without need to go withdraw and then hope I Get right value, this is true especially when removing 2 or more positions, annoying to use calculator to estimate value.
Again I understand long term buy and hold etc , but this is a beta and needs polishing for final product.
Dividend reinvesting is not how I expected, it seems it just stays in pie funds wait for new auto funding to invest. Anyway I hope we have option to tick/untick companies we donāt want to reinvest dividend in , even tho I am not sure how it would work.
I would like to be able to set some price range for when some stock gets autoinvested in when not.
I appreciate some folks want to just keep buying even when valuation is insane, but I would really like to be able predetermined what price range is OK for each position. In that case one should also define range of weightings min/max and desired, thus in case 10 positions become overvalued their weightings become 0% for future autoinvest, other companies weightings increase. I guess it is near āautobalanceā because one would expect overvalued to have overweight, other will be underweight, but anyway would like option to micromanage this.
Other obvious is clicking within pie on stock, nothing happening, also would be cool to see pie position on each stock, in case one stock is in more pies there is no way to know exact share count.
Thatās it for nowā¦
Cheers for great work so far @Team212.
5 Likes
I agree with all @Vedran has suggested but would like for those things to be optional. There may be times when I want to sell after removing from pie and there may be times when I donāt, however the times I do should not be so hard to do what I want. Currently it is quite a bit of effort what could just be one prompt āwould you like to sell the shares you have removed from the pieā with yes and no options after pressing save.
The dividend reinvestment also could be cleaner with the information on at what point it will be autoinvested. Like a notice in the dividend section saying āwill only reinvest with manual depositā, āwill reinvest when dividend and cash in pie reaches Ā£X amountā or something.
1 Like
totally with you on the execution times. i still hold the record for waiting 40 mins on a completely liquid stock to have it bought into my pie.
the rest are good to have points too.
When creating the pie, I accidentally skipped the part where I should set the amount and schedule for autoinvest. I was looking at the āfund pieā button and wondering, why it wants to fund 1000 Eur each month. I actually went back and could not find it. Then I accidentally scrolled one of the screens and there it was - bellow the fold. Really really hard to find.
The last screen with āfund pieā contains a lots of free space above and bellow the content while the actual content needs to be scrolled into view (can show about 3 lines on my phone). The screen is big enough to show nice overview of everything without scrolling.
Funding and investing went fine. Thanks for the feature! For me that was the driver for creating account with trading212 (I already use Degiro, Fio and Revolut).
1 Like
Hey @George! I have the exact same issue as @Darthicc!
Can you provide any insight? I donāt have lots of cash in my account either.
Please see image
I created separate pies for different sectors that way the the minimum investment is somewhere between 1ā¬-6ā¬
He already replied to this above. If you want Ā£20 youāll need the smallest fraction as 1%. For Ā£10 the smallest fraction must be 2% and so on.
2 Likes
For the auto invest schedule settings ādailyā I miss the possibility to exclude the weekend days Saturday and Sunday.
Yes you will have 3 x investment on Monday. This is a known issue like to be resolved soon.
Iāve had a quick look and I may be wrong. But can you not add stocks to a pie which you own before hand?
Thatās pointless if Iām correct. 
Yes you definitely can, Iāve got several stocks I owned āout of a pieā and then created a pie with those same stocks in.
Possibly the stock isnāt fractional? All stocks in pies need to be fractional because of the varying monetary amounts you end up investing into pie slices.
Hi Ben
But what you already own out of the pie isnāt included when you create a pie. Is that correct?
Correct, so when I look at the stock at the moment it looks like this:
In the future you will be able to move stocks into and out of pies, so I guess when that feature is developed I will move a load of my āout of pieā investments into the pie.
Itās a beta. Thinking as a software developer for moment, would you want 100ās of millions of pounds worth of assets poured into your beta when your not entirely sure youāve ironed out all the issues 100%?
5 Likes